Anthropic’s record-setting IPO on Thursday is the second trillion-dollar-plus IPO this year after SpaceX. Anthropic has grown faster than any company in history. OpenAI could IPO in 2027 at a valuation of more than a trillion dollars too. Critics on the left, and increasingly on the populist right, worry about the dominance of these new AI companies and talk openly of breaking up Big Tech.
Read more Voters Didn’t Reject Conservatism. They Rejected Tariffs.
These fears are overblown because dominance earned in competitive markets doesn’t last. Only dominance protected by the government does. Critics of free markets have raised the specter of monopoly, or “market concentration,” for centuries. The concern never goes away, even as “monopolies” pile up in the dustbin of history.
We should worry less about bigness and more about losing a free and competitive economy through heavy-handed government intervention.
In the late 1800s, concerns about monopolies reached a fever pitch as new forms of corporate governance (trusts) emerged alongside the massive fortunes of Cornelius Vanderbilt, John D. Rockefeller, Andrew Carnegie, and J.P. Morgan. Congress responded with the Sherman Antitrust Act (1890), and then the Clayton Act and the Federal Trade Commission Act (both 1914).
The federal government famously used the Sherman Act against Rockefeller’s Standard Oil, and in 1911 the Supreme Court broke the company into 34 smaller pieces. But Standard Oil’s market share was already falling before the Court acted. Or consider U.S. Steel. Assembled by J.P. Morgan in 1901, at one point it produced roughly two-thirds of the nation’s steel. The government sued to break it up and lost in 1920. Yet its market share declined for decades until Japan’s Nippon Steel bought it in 2025.
Sears was America’s dominant retailer for most of the century, yet filed for bankruptcy in 2018. Kodak sold roughly 90 percent of the film in the United States in the 1970s, then filed for bankruptcy in 2012, outcompeted by the digital camera it had itself invented. The Justice Department pursued IBM for 13 years before dropping the case in 1982 as “without merit.” By then, the personal computer was already eroding IBM’s dominance. No one worries about any of these companies cornering the market today.
Walmart is a particularly interesting case. In the early 2000s, there was widespread panic that it would drive every competitor and every local retailer out of business, and towns fought to keep its stores out. Such concerns seem quaint today with Costco, IKEA, and many other stores thriving. Not to mention the fact that Amazon recently surpassed Walmart in annual revenue.
Meanwhile, companies that come to dominate through competition create incredible benefits for consumers: better technology and lower prices. Standard Oil, perhaps the greatest symbol of “unfair” business practices and monopolistic hegemony, drove kerosene prices from 58 cents per gallon in 1865 to 26 cents in 1870, and to about 8 cents by the end of the 1870s. As historian Burton Folsom documents in The Myth of the Robber Barons, prices fell even further in the 1880s, an incredible decline of roughly 90 percent during Standard Oil’s rise to dominance.
Folsom draws a crucial distinction between market entrepreneurs, who succeed by offering better products at lower prices, and political entrepreneurs, who succeed by winning subsidies and privileges from the government. Market dominance invites competition and eventually declines. Political dominance is far harder to dislodge.
Read more Democrats Hate That Parents Are Choosing How to Educate Their Own Kids
Regulation in the name of preventing “predatory” business practices often benefits incumbents and allows them to keep prices high.
That is the irony of trust-busting: it often led to stagnation rather than consumer benefits. The regulation of railroads kept prices from falling. So too did regulation of airlines under the now-defunct Civil Aeronautics Board. Regulation in the name of preventing “predatory” business practices often benefits incumbents and allows them to keep prices high. (READ NEXT: Wealth Is Not Coercive Power)
Perhaps this time is different, people will say. Perhaps the new tech titans cannot be unseated. After all, Microsoft has maintained a top-10 position for about 30 years. JPMorgan Chase is more than twice as valuable as its nearest competitor. Google, Amazon, Meta, and Microsoft all seem unstoppable. Perhaps they all have moats that ensure they will dominate their industries for decades to come.
But new competition springs up from unexpected quarters. Apple is one of the corporate giants now, but 30 years ago it was nearly dead. Tesla, SpaceX, and Nvidia (briefly the most valuable company in the world) were small or nonexistent when the government dropped its IBM case. How many large companies do we need before we recognize robust competition?
AI itself is the best example. OpenAI is about 10 years old, and Anthropic is just five, yet each now brings in revenue at an annual pace that would place it among the top 100 companies on the Fortune 500. People already worry about a new monopoly, or a duopoly. But these firms compete fiercely with each other and with Google, Meta, xAI, Chinese rivals, and free open-source models. The result is what competition always delivers: the price of using AI has fallen dramatically while its capabilities have soared. These firms are multiplying people’s capacity to get work done and to create new and better things at a relatively small cost.
The point is not that big companies today will simply disappear (Walmart is still doing well, and GE Aerospace is thriving even after GE broke itself apart). It is that in free and competitive economies, there will always be a new kid on the block disrupting things. Yes, the scale of industry today has grown. Yes, the meteoric rise of new companies can be breathtaking. But there is little reason to think that today’s biggest companies will be tomorrow’s biggest companies. The historical record is clear on this point.
Conservatives tempted by trust-busting should remember that lesson. We should worry less about bigness and more about losing a free and competitive economy through heavy-handed government intervention. If we can constrain our political and legal institutions from intervening in markets to benefit large incumbents, we can trust the competitive market to bring us new, better, and cheaper products and to ensure that no company ever gains an insurmountable position.
Read more Democrats’ New Plan to Bypass the Electoral College
READ MORE from Paul Mueller:
Wealth Is Not Coercive Power
The Trillion-Dollar Illusion
Real and Imagined Benefits of Trump Accounts