Among the many regrettable outcomes of last week’s midterm elections is a significant increase in the number of states in which Democrats gained governing trifectas. Specifically, they took control of state legislatures and governorships in Pennsylvania, Michigan, Arizona, Wisconsin, and Nevada. Combined with the 18 states the Democrats controlled before the midterms, this means they theoretically have the power to nullify the Electoral College by joining the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC). For those unfamiliar with NPVIC, it’s a Democratic scheme to change the way we elect presidents without messing with that pesky constitutional amendment process.
Read more Socialists Always and Everywhere Eventually Devour Their Own
All of this can be avoided if the Democrats were truly interested in “one person, one vote.” It could be accomplished without NPVIC.
How would NPVIC achieve this miracle? Pursuant to a formal agreement among states controlling 270 or more presidential electors, each member of the compact would be required to cast all of its electoral votes for the candidate who wins the national popular vote — without regard to the winner of the popular vote in any single state. For instance, if NPVIC had been in effect during the 2024 presidential election a member state like Colorado would have been forced to cast its 10 electoral votes for Donald Trump, despite the fact that Kamala Harris won the Centennial State by double digits. Yet its advocates insist NPVIC would be more democratic than the Electoral College:
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact would guarantee the Presidency to the candidate who receives the most popular votes across all 50 states and the District of Columbia … The winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes repeatedly generates controversies over real or imagined irregularities and incentivizes hair-splitting litigation. A mere 537 popular votes in one state decided the national outcome in 2000. An average of only about 280,000 popular votes spread over one, two, or three closely divided states decided the last seven presidential elections. In contrast, the national-popular-vote lead averaged 4,327,902 votes over the last seven.
If all five of the states listed above decide to join NPVIC, then the total number of electoral votes controlled by the compact’s members would increase to 283, thirteen more than the 270 its members claim they need to bypass the Electoral College. The 18 states that have already joined NPVIC are the usual suspects: California (54), Colorado (10), Connecticut (7), Delaware (3), Hawaii (4), Illinois (19), Maine (4), Maryland (10), Massachusetts (11), Minnesota (10), New Jersey (14), New Mexico (5), New York (28), Oregon (8), Rhode Island (4), Vermont (3), Virginia (13), Washington (12), and the District of Columbia (3). These 23 states would, according to the stipulations of NPVIC, choose the president without the consent of the other 27 states or their voters.
Read more No American Senator Should Swear on a Quran, and No Oaths on a Quran Should Be Accepted
It isn’t clear that the remaining 27 states will be inclined to accept being locked out of the presidential selection process without challenging the constitutionality of NPVIC. And it isn’t difficult to guess on what grounds they would base a challenge. Article I, Section 10, Clause 3 of the Constitution states the following: “No State shall, without the Consent of Congress … enter into any Agreement or Compact with another State.” Because the Democrats will control both Houses of Congress, they will be far friendlier to NPVIC than the current Congress, but they won’t have a filibuster-proof majority of 60 votes in the Senate. And, as Cato Institution’s Paul E. Godek writes, NPVIC will force some member states to disenfranchise their own voters.
First, joining the NPVIC means that the assignment of a state’s electoral votes in a future election will not be in accordance with the will of the majority of the state’s voters. That outcome is, indeed, the explicit method of the NPVIC. If the winner of a state’s popular vote is the loser of the national popular vote, then the electors will be allocated contrary to the majority of that state’s voters. By joining the NPVIC, therefore, a state commits itself to disenfranchising its own voters, nullifying their votes in some future election. Disenfranchisement would seem to violate the plain text of the Constitution, which guarantees the vote to all eligible citizens.
All of this can be avoided if the Democrats were truly interested in “one person, one vote.” It could be accomplished without NPVIC. The states could pursue genuine reform by simply choosing to allocate their electoral votes proportionally. Nebraska and Maine have already changed their allocation systems to something approximating this method, and it involves no conflict with the Constitution. It would, however, reduce the enormous electoral power wielded by the largest Democratic states. In California, which contains the largest number of Republicans of any other state, more than 20 of its 54 electoral votes would go to the “Grand Old Party.”
This is why no Democrat-controlled state would dream of going to a fully proportional system. It is why they have concocted the unconstitutional and undemocratic National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. They aren’t interested in genuine electoral reform, and the claim that NPVIC is a “conservative compromise” doesn’t pass the laugh test. They want to shift more power to heavily populated, Democrat-dominated regions and keep the electoral advantage they already possess in large states like California, New York, and now even Texas. NPVIC is, in the final analysis, just another Democrat scheme to rig the game. It’s just what they do.
Read more Jim Jordan and the Politics of the Takedown
READ MORE from David Catron:
Alaska’s Ranked-Choice Voting Experiment Takes a Sinister Turn
Black Enthusiasm Gap Haunts Far Left Democrats
James Talarico’s 12-Day Campaign Absence Deserves Scrutiny in Texas